The young native Hemlocks [Tsuga canadensis]that I see planted in people’s yards on gardening shows are fairly small and dense, but as they get older they thin out considerably, and get very tall. Then, like many evergreens, some of the lowest branches die back because they aren’t getting any light down there. And yes, this is true of shade-loving Hemlocks too.
The rule is to remove deadwood because it’s an entry point for disease, but to be honest I couldn’t see any evidence that that was an issue here. It was more a case of aesthetics. Aesthetics and weeds. They don’t really show in this photo as far as I can tell, but there was a regular ‘nursery’ of tree seedlings developing in the shade of this Hemlock and the easiest way to be able to weed under there was to get rid of the deadwood first. I try my best not to leave stubs – both for the trees sake and for mine. Stubs snag anything they can, look unsightly, and interfere with the trees ability to close the wound left by removing the branch. The smaller the branch, the smaller the wound and the more quickly it heals.
The weeding still involved crawling around on my hands and knees, but at least there were no longer any dead branches trying to scratch my face. I did this pruning in the middle of July or the middle of summer (depending which hemisphere you live in), but since all I was doing was removing deadwood and weeding, I could presumably have done it at just about any time of the year. (OK not the middle of winter, but just because it’s too bloody cold.)
In order to do these photos, I got in under the living ‘skirt’ of the tree. If you stood back, the work I did wouldn’t be particularly noticeable, it would just somehow look a little lighter and neater, but not in an obvious way.